The Avignon Papacy
For nearly a thousand years, the identity of the Pope was inseparable from the city of Rome. The “Eternal City” was the site of St. Peter’s martyrdom and the spiritual anchor of the West. But in 1309, that anchor was cut loose. For the next seventy years, the head of the Catholic Church would not reside on the banks of the Tiber, but on the banks of the Rhône in southern France.
This period, famously dubbed the “Babylonian Captivity of the Church” by the poet Petrarch, represents one of the most controversial chapters in medieval history. It was an era of unprecedented administrative genius, staggering wealth, and a deep crisis of legitimacy that would eventually tear the Church apart.
The Flight from Rome
The move to Avignon was born out of fear and political pressure. Following the humiliation and death of Boniface VIII, the papacy was effectively under the thumb of the French monarchy. When the Frenchman Clement V was elected Pope in 1305, he refused to move to Rome. The city was a chaotic war zone of feuding noble families, and the French King, Philip the Fair, was pressuring the new Pope to stay close.
In 1309, Pope Clement set up his court in Avignon. While technically a papal fief and not part of the Kingdom of France, its proximity to French power was undeniable. To the rest of Europe, it appeared that the “Vicar of Christ” had become the “Chaplain of the King of France.”
The Palais des Papes: A Fortress of Faith
If the Popes were “captives,” they were living in the most luxurious cage ever built. During this time, the papacy constructed the Palais des Papes (Palace of the Popes), a massive, fortress-like Gothic complex that still dominates the Avignon skyline today.
Under the Avignon Popes, seven in total and all of them French, the Church became a master of centralization and bureaucracy.
Because the Popes lost the income from their Italian lands, they developed sophisticated new ways to tax the faithful across Europe. They sold “expectancies” (promises of future church offices) and perfected the sale of indulgences.
The papal court in Avignon became the most efficient legal machine in the world. If you wanted a marriage annulled or a legal dispute settled anywhere in Christendom, your gold flowed toward France.
The “Babylonian” Scandal
While the Church’s bank accounts grew, its reputation withered. The name “Babylonian Captivity” was a deliberate reference to the biblical exile of the Israelites in Babylon. Critics like Petrarch described Avignon as a “sink of all vices” and a “sewer of the world,” claiming the Popes were living in sybaritic luxury while Rome fell into ruin.
The perception was that the Papacy had lost its soul. The Popes in Avignon were seen as political pawns of the French during the Hundred Years’ War against England. This created a massive rift: how could an English or German Christian trust a Pope who was effectively a neighbor and ally of the French King?
The Return: Catherine of Siena and Gregory XI
As the decades passed, the cry for the Pope to return to Rome became deafening. The most powerful voice was that of St. Catherine of Siena, a mystic and diplomat who wrote scorching letters to Pope Gregory XI. She told him that the “stench” of the Avignon court had reached heaven and urged him to “be a man” and return to the seat of St. Peter.
In 1377, Gregory XI finally made the journey back. He found Rome in a state of collapse, grass was growing in the streets of St. Peter’s, and the population had dwindled to a fraction of its former size. He died shortly after his return, setting the stage for an even greater disaster.
Legacy
The Avignon Papacy wasn’t a period of failure in terms of power; in many ways, the Church had never been more organized. However, it was a failure of prestige. By abandoning Rome, the Popes proved that the Papacy could be moved, which suggested it could be controlled by secular kings.
The attempt to move back to Rome in 1378 went so poorly that it led to the Great Western Schism, a period where two (and eventually three) men all claimed to be the true Pope at the same time. The “Golden Cage” of Avignon had been broken, but the Church that emerged was fractured, cynical, and ripe for the calls of reform that would eventually lead to the Protestant Reformation.
Read more articles in The Medieval Papacy series
Pope John XV: Politics, Power, and the First Papal Canonization
Pope Pelagius I: The Controversial Sixth-Century Pope
Pope Gregory XI: The Pope Who Returned to Rome
Pope Innocent IV: The Pope Who Challenged Emperors and Encountered the Mongols
Pope Paschal II: The Pope Who Tried to End the Investiture Controversy
Pope Benedict XII: The Hammer of Heresy and the Architect of a Papal Fortress
🏰 Medieval Archives Weekly
Love stories like this? Every week we deliver papal struggles, forgotten battles and royal intrigue of the Middle Ages
2026 Special Feature
2026 marks the 960th anniversary of the Norman Conquest. To celebrate, our weekly newsletter is embarking on a year-long journey through the Bayeux Tapestry.
Every week, we “unroll” a new panel, decoding the secrets, the drama and the history of 1066.
Join thousands of fellow medievalists and sign up for free.
